Timmy becomes the baseball star on their baseball team "the Losers" (from Foul balled) by using Cosmo and Wanda. When walking home from the game, he sees a soccer field. Kids are playing soccer and one kid kicks the ball towards Timmy. Timmy gets scared (Thinking the ball is going to hit him hard) and kicks it toward one teams goal. the team that he kicks to wins and they ask Timmy to join their soccer team called "the Green Stars". Timmy thinks this is a game where he doesn't need Cosmo and Wanda's help. Timmy says yes and joins the team. Meanwhile, Timmy asks Chester if he likes soccer, A.J. overhears this and says that soccer is girly. Chester agrees with him and Timmy decides not to tell them that he became a soccer player. While trying to keep his secret, he plays soccer and baseball knowing that they won't be at the same time. He does this for 5 weeks. The problem then comes in when the Losers and the Green Stars both are entering the championship. Timmy thinks he can handle it. Until he looks at the schedule and finds out that the championships are at the same time on the same day. Timmy can't decide what to do. He knows he can't go to both at the same time, and he knows he can't go to either of them. So Timmy gets an idea! Timmy wishes that he had a baseball star clone that can play twice as good as he can. The real Timmy goes to the soccer championship and the clone Timmy will play baseball. Turns out that in the end, the both win. But when Timmy wishes that the clone was gone, the clone goes away. But when Chester and A.J. are walking home, they see Timmy at the soccer field! When they find this out, they feel bad that they said soccer was girly. So they go to Timmy and apologize.